Your therapist asks what happened this week, and you hear yourself say, "It was just a bad one. Same as always. I felt kind of off." She nods and waits. You know there was something more, a particular afternoon or a particular sentence. But when you reach for it, you find a gray summary where the scene should be.
You probably aren't hiding it. In some ways it's worse: the scene may never have been stored in a form you can retrieve. And in therapy, the scene is usually where the work is.
The shape of a vague memory
Psychologists have a name for this pattern: overgeneral autobiographical memory. It was described most influentially by J. Mark G. Williams and colleagues, who gave people cue words like "happy" or "angry" and asked them to recall a specific event, one that happened on a particular day and lasted less than a day. People who were depressed, or who had lived through trauma, were more likely to answer with categories instead of events. Not "the Tuesday my sister cancelled dinner," but "my family never makes time for me."
This isn't a character flaw or a lack of effort. Williams proposed an account often called CaRFAX, with three working parts:
- Capture and rumination. When your search for a memory lands on a self-critical theme, such as "I'm always left out," you get pulled into that theme and stop before you reach the particular event.
- Functional avoidance. Specific memories carry specific pain. Staying at the level of summary keeps you from re-feeling the scene, so the vagueness protects you. It also costs you.
- Impaired executive control. Digging from a general category down to a single episode takes mental effort, and that effort is in short supply when you're low, anxious, or exhausted.
The point worth holding onto is that vagueness is often protective before it is anything else.
Why therapy runs on scenes
A summary can't be treated, but a scene can. "I always feel dismissed" gives your therapist almost nothing to work with. "On Thursday, I told my manager about the deadline, he said 'we'll see,' and I felt my chest go tight and said nothing" gives them a trigger, a body response, a thought, and a behavior. That's the raw material of nearly every approach to therapy, from cognitive work to behavior chains to relational exploration.
Summaries also feed the problem they describe. General statements like "I'm always the one who gets left out" are easy to believe because no single memory contradicts them. A specific scene has edges. It may reveal that three people did include you and one didn't. Specificity doesn't make your pain smaller. It makes it accurate, and accurate things can change.
There's a practical angle too. Research on memory specificity training, developed by Filip Raes and colleagues, suggests that practicing the retrieval of specific events can make recall more specific, and that this shift may be tied to better coping with rumination. I wouldn't oversell this: it's a promising line of work and not a cure. But the underlying idea is sound. Specific recall is a skill, and a skill can be practiced.
How the vagueness shows up in a session
Once you know the pattern, you start to hear it:
- "I've just been really anxious." (Where? When did it peak?)
- "We had another fight." (What was the first thing said?)
- "I always shut down." (What did your face and hands do the last time?)
- "Nothing really happened." (Something made you feel it was worth coming in.)
None of these are wrong. They're the first layer, and the scene sits one question underneath.
The trick: ask for the moment, not the meaning
When you're trying to find a specific memory, don't ask "what does this say about me?" That question invites the rumination loop and sends you straight back to the category. Ask smaller, stubbier questions instead. Where was I standing? What did the room look like? What was the very first thing that was said? What did I do with my hands?
These are the questions of a witness, not a judge. They keep you at the level of detail, and detail is what pulls an episode out of the summary.
Your next moves
- Pick one "scene of the week" today. Before your next session, choose a single moment from the last seven days that had some charge, even a small one. Write down the day, time of day, and place. If you can name those three things, you have a scene and not a theme.
- Write the first ten seconds. Describe only the opening of that moment: who spoke, what they said, what you noticed. Skip the interpretation. Opening moments are easier to retrieve than whole events, and they tend to pull the rest along with them.
- Add one sensory detail and one body note. What did you see or hear, and what did you feel in your body? Four words is enough: "tight jaw, fluorescent lights."
- Catch your summary words. Look at your last few journal entries or texts to a friend and circle "always," "never," "everyone," and "just." Next to each, write one real instance you can actually date.
- Start the session with the scene, not the conclusion. Say, "Thursday, around two, my manager said..." before you say anything about how your week was. Let your therapist ask what it means.
Do this when you're calm and not in the middle of a bad stretch. Retrieval gets harder the lower your mood sits, so catching scenes soon after they happen beats trying to dig them up on the way to the appointment.
A note on kindness
If this practice makes you flinch, treat that as information and not as failure. The vagueness has been doing a job for you, which is keeping the sharp edges at a distance. You don't have to dismantle that all at once. One scene a week is plenty, and you can choose a mild one first. Therapy can also be where you practice staying with a scene a little longer than usual, with someone beside you who knows how to help if it gets to be too much.
Where this leaves your sessions
The version of you who walks into the room is often the version who has already summarized the week into a mood. Capturing the moment while it's still fresh is how you keep the real material from collapsing into "it was fine, I guess." That's the idea behind Sesh: a private place to hold the specific, in-the-moment pieces of what came up in therapy and between sessions, so the details are still there when you need them. If that sounds useful, you can find it at sesh.lumenlabs.works. The scene-of-the-week habit works just as well with a notebook, though.